Best Turkey Deals or Sales in Ohio (2015)

(Last Updated On: November 17, 2015)

Ohio Turkey Deals 2015

Welcome to the 2nd annual Eat Like No One Else guide to buying a turkey in the 17th state, Ohio. Last year I decided to expand my ever popular turkey deals list to the state just to the south of me. I was met with equal succes, so I am back at it again this year.

This list includes many of the store in Ohio but not necessarily every one. If you find one missing, leave a comment below and I will add it to the list.

Cheapest Turkey Price in the State of Ohio – Just as in my home state, Meijer is the champion of the cheapest turkey with their 52 cents per pound price on their Meijer brand frozen turkeys.

Whole Foods Market
Locations in Columbus,
Fresh Brined Turkey $2.99/lb
Fresh Boneless Turkey Breast $6.99/lb
Fresh Whole Heirloom Bronze Turkey Non-GMO Verified $3.69/lb
Fresh Bone-In Turkey Breast $4.99/lb
Whole Free Range Turkey $2.69/lb
Fresh Kosher Turkey $3.49/lb
Fresh Organic Turkey $3.99/lb

Various locations throughout the state.
For the 2nd year in a row Meijer is offering 50& off all frozen or fresh turkeys with an additional $20 purchase.

Here are some example prices with the 50% off:
Meijer Frozen Turkey $.52/lb
Meijer Fresh Turkey $1.49/lb

Lucky’s Market
Location in Columbus
Amish Country All-Natural Fresh Turkey $1.39/lb
Plainville Antibotic-Free Fresh Turkey $1.99/lb
Mary’s Organic Free Range Turkey (the ad says to contact them about this one)

Jungle Jim’s International Market
Locations in Fairfield and Cincinnati, OH
Amish Country Fresh Turkeys $1.99/lb
Frozen Grade A Turkey Breats $1.59/lb
Honeysuckle Frozen Whole Smoked Turkeys $2.59/lb
Butterball Frozen Turkeys $1.39/lb (no limit)

Walt Churchill’s Market
Locations in Maumee and Perrysburg, OH
You can pre-order Bowman Landes Fresh Whole Turkey or Turkey Breast. Contact the store for more details.

Giant Eagle
Various locations throughout Ohio
Giant Eagle says “We Won’t Be Beat”. They will match any competitor’s price on frozen whole turkeys.

Giant Eagle Frozen Turkeys USDA Grade A, All sizes $0.98 lb. With an additional $25 purchase, limit 2
Honeysuckle White Frozen Turkeys USDA Grade A, 18 lbs. and up $1.09 lb. with an additional $25 purchase.
Butterball Frozen Turkeys $1.59 lb.
Nature’s Basket Fresh or Frozen Turkeys $2.89/lb
Plainville Farms or Bells & Evan Fresh Turkey $2.99/lb
Giant Eagle Fresh Turkeys, USDA Grade A, All Sizes $1.69 lb.
Honeysuckle Whole Fresh Turkeys $1.89/lb
Butterball Fresh Turkeys $1.99/lb
Honeysuckle Frozen Turkey Breasts $1.99/lb
Giant Eagle Fresh Turkey Breasts $3.69/lb

The Andersons
Locations in Toledo, Maumee, Sylvania, and Columbus, OH
No prices advertised as of yet.

Acme Fresh Market
Various locations across Ohio
Acme Frozen Turkey $.59/lb, limit 1 with card
Honeysuckle White Frozen Turkey $.99/lb with card
Buckley Farms Bone-In Turkey Breast $1.89/lb with card
Butterball Frozen Turkey $1.59/lb with card

The Fresh Market
Locations in Cincinnati, Columbus, Shaker Heights, Toledo, West Chester
Check with store to pre-order your turkey.

Buehler’s Grocery
Various locations across Ohio
Honeysuckle White Frozen Turkey $.99/lb, limit 1 (additional turkeys will be $1.49/lb)
Honeysuckle White Fresh Turkey $1.99/lb
Honeysuckle Frozen Boneless Turkey Breast $13.99 for 3 pounds
Butterball Frozen Turkey $1.79/lb

Locations in the Cleveland Metro area
No prices listed online, contact store for pricing information
Planville Fresh Turkeys (antibiotic and hormone free)
Amish Country All-Natural Turkey (raised without antibiotic or added hormones)
Frozen Empire Kosher Turkey
Honeysuckle Frozen Turkey
Butterball Frozen Turkey

Various location across Ohio
Fresh Honeysuckle Turkey $1.49/lb
Kroger Frozen Turkey $.98/lb
Honeysuckle or Private selection Frozen Turkey $1.29/lb
Honeysuckle Turkey Breast $1.69/lb

Trader Joe’s
Locations in Cincinnati, Kettering, Woodmere, Westlake, Columbus, Dublin
Trader Joe’s All Natural, Brined, Fresh Young Turkeys (12-22 pound birds) for $1.99 per pound
Glatt Kosher, All Natural, Fresh Young Turkeys (12-16 pound birds) for $2.49 per pound.

Chief Market
Locations in Paulding, Wauseon, Delphos, Celina, Coldwater, Defiance, Bryan
Prices not available currently.

Earth Fare
Locations in Dayton, Akron, Cleveland, Columbus
Fresh Free Range Organic Turkey $4.29/lb
Natural, Hormone & antibiotic free fresh Turkey $2.69/lb
Bone-In Fresh Natural Turkey Breast $5.99/lb
Boneless Fresh Turkey Breast $6.99/lb

Dorothy Lane Market
Locations in Dayton and Springboro
DLM Fresh Free-Range Turkey $3.39/lb (price down 60 cents a pound from last year!)
DLM Fresh Free-Range Turkey Breast $6.19/lb
Heavenly Turkey Breasts $8.99/lb
Whole Herb Brined Turkey $4.29/lb

Marsh Stores
Locations in Southwest Ohio
Norbest, Jennie-O or Honeysuckle Frozen Turkey $.69/lb (limit 1, with additional $25 purchase)
Butterball All Natural Frozen Turkey $.89/lb (limit 1, with additional $25 purchase)